⛳️ The Value Prop Secret: Your Product Is a Painkiller (You Just Don't Know It Yet)

^{If you had to pick one person who’d love this newsletter as much as you do - who comes to mind? Got them? Good. Now go ahead and hit forward, they’ll thank you later! Just click “forward” now, thank you!}

Value Proposition Design: Are You Selling a Vitamin or a Painkiller?

Hey everyone, Happy Monday! For the past sixteen editions, we've laid the essential foundation for research and creative. Now, we're leveling up. Welcome to the intermediate phase, where we take those foundations and build campaigns that dominate.

Let's start with a brutal question that will define your entire marketing strategy: Is your product a "vitamin" or a "painkiller?"

• A vitamin is a "nice-to-have." It's good for you, it might help over time, but you don't urgently need it right now.

• A painkiller is a "MUST-HAVE." It solves an immediate, sharp, throbbing pain. People will drop everything and pay a premium for relief.

Most brands market their products like vitamins. The top 1% know how to frame their product - no matter what it is - as a painkiller. Today, in our return to Module 1: Product Research, we're showing you how to find that acute pain and make your product the essential solution.

Here’s the game-changing strategy we're breaking down today:

• Why you're stuck in a "price war" if you're selling a vitamin.

• A simple framework to find the "throbbing pain" your product solves.

• How to reframe your product's value proposition from a "nice-to-have" to an urgent "must-have."

• An AI prompt to help you transform your pitch from vitamin to painkiller.

This is one of the biggest levers you can pull. Let's do it.

🔍 The Big Idea: People Pay to End Pain. Position Your Product as the Ultimate Relief.

Here's the truth: customers will delay buying a "vitamin." They'll shop around for the cheapest one. They'll tell themselves they'll get it "later." But when they have a splitting headache, they'll run to the store and buy a "painkiller" right now, and they won't care if it costs a few dollars more.

If you are marketing your product's features or nice-to-have benefits, you are selling a vitamin. If you are marketing your product as the fastest, most effective solution to a deep, urgent, and frustrating pain, you are selling a painkiller. The product doesn't have to change; the framing does. This is the core of a powerful value proposition.

🧱 The Framework: The "Painkiller" Litmus Test

Run your product through this simple, three-step reframing process:

1. Identify Your Current "Vitamin" Pitch:

   • What's the nice, polite, feature-focused way you currently describe your product? Write it down. Be honest.

   • Vitamin Example (for a project management tool): "Our tool helps teams stay organized with calendars, to-do lists, and file sharing." (This is a vitamin. It's nice, but not urgent).

2. Find the ACUTE Pain (The "Bleeding Neck" Problem):

   • Dig into your customer research (Module 2). What is the real-world consequence of the problem your product solves? What deep frustration or fear does it create?

   • Don't stop at "disorganized." Go deeper. What does disorganization cause?

   • Pain Example: "The constant, gut-wrenching anxiety of a looming deadline you might miss. The fear of letting a client down and losing their business. The chaos of team members working on the wrong things, wasting time and money." (This is the pain).

3. Forge Your New "Painkiller" Value Proposition:

   • Directly connect your product to eliminating that sharp, specific pain. This becomes your new core message.

   • Painkiller Example: "Stop letting project chaos kill your deadlines and your reputation. Our tool gives you iron-clad control over every project, so you can end the anxiety, deliver on time, and never let a client down again."

Now, every ad, every headline, every email is built on this powerful, pain-focused foundation.

🧠 Real-Life Application: Transform Your Pitch Right Now

Take your main product. Write down its current "vitamin" pitch. Now, using your customer knowledge, identify the most acute, frustrating, painful problem it solves. What's the thing that keeps your customers up at night?

Now, rewrite your product's one-sentence description to be the direct painkiller for THAT specific pain. You've just shifted from selling a feature to selling relief. That's a much more powerful position.

🧰 Bonus: AI Prompt – The "Value Prop Converter: Vitamin to Painkiller"

Use AI to help you find the pain and reframe your value proposition.

ACT AS A WORLD-CLASS BRAND STRATEGIST who excels at finding deep-seated customer pain points.
I have a product that is currently positioned as a 'Vitamin' (a nice-to-have). I need your help to reframe it as a 'Painkiller' (a must-have solution to an urgent, acute problem).

My Product: [e.g., "A high-end, chef-quality kitchen knife"]
Current 'Vitamin' Pitch: [e.g., "Our knife is sharp, well-balanced, and makes chopping easier."]
My Target Audience: [e.g., "Home cooks who enjoy cooking and want good tools."]

YOUR TASK:
1.  Brainstorm 3 potential **ACUTE PAINS or deep frustrations** this target audience experiences in the kitchen that a bad knife makes worse. Think beyond just "dull knives." Think about the emotional consequences.
2.  Based on the strongest pain point, write a new, hard-hitting **"Painkiller" Value Proposition** for my knife.
3.  Suggest ONE powerful, pain-focused **Headline** for a Meta ad based on this new 'Painkiller' proposition.

Example AI Output (for the kitchen knife):

1. ACUTE PAINS:

   • The immense frustration and wasted time of struggling to prep ingredients with a dull knife, turning a creative joy (cooking) into a chore.

   • The fear of slipping with a dull knife and getting a nasty cut.

   • The disappointment of crushing delicate ingredients like herbs or tomatoes with a bad knife, ruining the final dish.

2. "Painkiller" Value Proposition: For home cooks who are tired of the frustration and danger of dull knives, our chef's knife provides a surgically sharp, perfectly controlled solution that eliminates prep-time struggle and lets you cook with confidence and joy again.

3. Killer Headline: Stop Fighting Your Food. The Right Knife Changes Everything.

The "Pain Matrix" & Product-Pain Alignment

Framing your product as a painkiller is a winning move. The top 0.1% take it two steps further to build an unshakeable market position.

1. The "Pain Matrix" – Find the Right Pain to Solve: Not all pains are created equal. Before you build a campaign, plot your brainstormed customer pains on this simple matrix:

• X-Axis (Frequency): How often does the customer feel this pain? (Hourly/Daily vs. Monthly/Rarely)

• Y-Axis (Intensity): How badly does it hurt? (A minor annoyance vs. A "business-killing" or "soul-crushing" problem)

Your "Painkiller Gold Zone" is in the top right: High-Frequency, High-Intensity pain. This is the "bleeding-neck" problem people will pay anything to solve. If your current marketing targets a low-frequency, low-intensity annoyance, you're leaving massive opportunity on the table.

ACTION: Plot your top 3 customer pain points on this matrix. Is your marketing focused on the Gold Zone?

2. Product-Pain Alignment – Engineer the Solution: This is the ultimate leverage: it's not just about marketing a painkiller; it's about engineering one. The validated, Gold Zone pain point shouldn't just inform your ads; it should dictate your product development.

• If your research proves the #1 pain is "wasted time entering data," your product team's #1 priority becomes building a feature that automates data entry.

• Your ad then isn't just claiming to solve the pain; it's demonstrating the specific feature that obliterates it.

This aligns your product and marketing into a single, unstoppable force. You're not just applying a marketing framework; you're building your entire business around solving your customer's most critical pain. That's how you create a category-defining brand.

The AI Prompt to Generate Your "Pain Matrix"

You can use this prompt with any modern AI tool like ChatGPT, Claude, or Gemini. Just copy, paste, and fill in the bracketed information with your own details.

Act as an expert Customer Research Analyst and Product Strategist. You are highly skilled at identifying deep-seated customer frustrations from raw, unstructured feedback.

My goal is to create a "Pain Matrix" to understand which customer problems are the most critical to solve. I need you to analyze a set of product reviews I've gathered and categorize the pain points based on their perceived frequency and intensity.

The product is: [Your Product Name or Type, e.g., "our 'EverCharge' portable power bank"]

Here are the customer reviews:
[Paste your raw customer reviews here. Copy as many reviews as you have for a particular product or attach a PDF file with reviews]

YOUR TASK:
1.  Read all the provided reviews carefully.
2.  Identify every distinct pain point, problem, or complaint mentioned by the customers.
3.  For each pain point, analyze the language used in the reviews to estimate its:
    * **Frequency:** Does this seem like a problem that happens often (e.g., daily, every use) or rarely (e.g., occasionally, one-time issue)?
    * **Intensity:** Does this problem sound like a major deal-breaker (using emotional words like "hate," "unusable," "nightmare," "frustrating") or a minor annoyance (using words like "wish," "could be better," "a little slow")?
4.  Place each identified pain point into one of the four quadrants below.
5.  For each pain point you list, include a short, representative quote from the reviews that justifies its placement in that quadrant.

Please present your final output in this exact format:

**--- PAIN MATRIX ANALYSIS ---**

**🔥 High-Frequency / High-Intensity (Gold Zone - Top Priority Problems):**
* [Pain Point 1]
    * *Quote:* "[Sample quote from reviews that shows high frequency and high intensity]"
* [Pain Point 2]
    * *Quote:* "[Sample quote]"

** nagging Annoyances (High-Frequency / Low-Intensity):**
* [Pain Point 1]
    * *Quote:* "[Sample quote that shows it happens often but is a minor issue]"
* [Pain Point 2]
    * *Quote:* "[Sample quote]"

**🚨 Critical but Rare Issues (Low-Frequency / High-Intensity):**
* [Pain Point 1]
    * *Quote:* "[Sample quote that shows it's a huge problem, but might not happen often]"

**Minor Gripes (Low-Frequency / Low-Intensity - Low Priority):**
* [Pain Point 1]
    * *Quote:* "[Sample quote that shows a minor issue that doesn't happen often]"

Why This Prompt Is So Effective:

• Sets a Clear Role: Tells the AI to think like a professional strategist.

• Defines the Goal: It understands the "why" behind your request (to build a Pain Matrix).

• Gives Specific Criteria: You've clearly defined "Frequency" and "Intensity," guiding the AI's analysis.

• Demands Proof: By asking for a representative quote for each pain point, you force the AI to justify its analysis, making the output far more trustworthy and actionable for you. You can see why it categorized a pain point in a certain quadrant.

Using this prompt will give you an incredibly clear, prioritized list of what to focus on, turning messy reviews into a strategic action plan.

💣 VALUE BOMB (The Core Truth of Selling!)

Customers don't buy products; they buy relief. They are trading their money for the relief of a nagging pain, a persistent frustration, or a deep-seated fear. Find their most acute pain that your product can heal. Your entire marketing message should then be about how you are the fastest, most effective, and most reliable relief for that specific pain.

🛠 TACTICAL TIP (Rewrite Your Homepage Headline TODAY!)

Go look at the main headline on your website's homepage right now. Is it a "vitamin" statement or a "painkiller" statement?

• If it says something like, "The Highest Quality Widgets Since 2015," that's a vitamin.

• If it says something like, "Stop Wasting Time on [Problem] and Finally [Achieve Desired Result]," that's a painkiller. Your Task: Rewrite your homepage headline today to focus on the sharpest pain you solve. Make it a painkiller.

To the next one, Tomasz.

Free resource by Vibe9.co

1. Newsletter previous editions

2. Free course: Creative Strategy For Social Media Advertisers

3. AI Creative Strategist: Ask it anything related to creative strategy

4. CMO custom GPT by Vibe9 your ruthless, high-IQ CMO who diagnoses root problems, eliminates weak strategy, and delivers system-level marketing clarity with zero tolerance for fluff or laziness.

5. Prompt GOD mode by Vibe9.co turns basic prompts into detailed, high-quality instructions.

6. Prompt Master by Vibe9 rewrites your request into a clean, structured prompt using a proven template.

7. Prompts library (comming soon)